
JSET ejournal







|
Research &
Practice
Associate Editor Column
Dave Edyburn
One characteristic commonly associated with the Information
Age is the
overwhelming amount of information that is produced and archived.
The glut
of information poses significant challenges for scholars and
practitioners who desire to maintain a high-degree of awareness
concerning new research and development within their discipline.
Although technology has contributed to the problem of information
overload, new tools are emerging which utilize technology to
monitor, retrieve, filter, sort, and organize personally relevant
information.
The purpose of this article is to describe nine tactics (see
Table 1) for utilizing technology to manage ever-increasing amounts
of information while attempting to discern what information is
most pertinent to one's personal and professional interests.
Specific products will be highlighted to provide a glimpse of
the potential power and value of these tools for enabling researchers,
educational leaders, and technology specialists to stay apprised
of new developments.
Networking
The exchange of information among scholars is a critical
component of the
knowledge creation process. Information gained through networking
can be invaluable in that it can renew enthusiasm for one's work,
serve as a source of inspiration, and offer critical "insider
information" that is not readily available through other
sources. As a result, technology tools that connect individual
scholars with the larger community are especially important,
valuable, and necessary for maintaining a high-level of current
awareness. Two technology tactics are described for facilitating
networking opportunities.
Tactic #1 Attend a Conference
Perhaps the most traditional approach for staying current
in one's discipline involved travel to a national conference.
Of course, this approach continues to have value. Three web sites
feature comprehensive listings of national and international
conferences and allow visitors to search by topic, geographic
area, dates, etc. to locate relevant conferences:
ERIC Calendar of Education-Related Conferences
http://io.aspensys.com/eric_cal/introduction.asp
Chronicle of Higher Education's Events in Academe
http://chronicle.com/events/
EdTech Conference Planner
http://www.thejournal.com/conferences/
These tools, individually and collectively, will assist you in
making the most of a travel budget. The opportunity to attend
a national conference is an excellent use of time and provides
invaluable networking opportunities.
Tactic #2 Join an E-Conference
The term "E-Conference" is an umbrella term used
to describe a range of
communication formats: discussion lists, interest groups, e-journals,
e-newsletters, Usenet newsgroups, forums, and chat groups. The
basic concept involves identifying a group with interests similar
to your interests, subscribing to the messaging system, and receiving
correspondence via email. To search for a group with interests
similar to yours:
The Directory of Scholarly and Professional E-Conference
http://www.n2h2.com/KOVACS
AERA ListServs
http://www.aera.net/resource/listserv.htm
The Directory of Publicly Accessible Mailing Lists
http://paml.net
This is a wonderful strategy for becoming familiar with issues
surrounding
a topic. Many participants simply observe the discussion but
do not participate; commonly known as "lurking." This
strategy seems to be an ideal way for novices to learn about
a topic over time. The chief drawback to this tactic is the voluminous
messages that are dumped into your email account. The result
is often comparable in time and effort to finding the needle
by rummaging through the haystack.
Searching
Undoubtedly, most readers have used a search engine to search
for information on the World Wide Web. Indeed, web searching
is a seductively simple process and can yield some interesting
and useful results. Unfortunately, more often than not, the results
are overwhelming and not particularly useful. In addition, significant
differences are found when using various search engines. As a
result, to improve the value of web
searches, it is helpful to understand the unique attributes of
each search engine. A tool to assist in this process is the Search
Engine Watch:
Search Engine Watch
http://www.searchenginewatch.com/
Tactic #3 Conduct a Web Search
A promising development in the area of search engines has
been the creation of meta-search tools. That is, search engines
that simultaneously submit a search to multiple search engines
and then co-mingle the results, eliminate duplicate entries,
and rank order the results based on relevance. Several metasearch
tools are available, including:
Google
http://www.google.com/
NorthernLight
http://www.northernlight.com/
DogPile
http://www.dogpile.com/
These tools are valuable to researchers because they are available
on-demand, are relatively easy to use, and save considerable
time compared to conducting repeated searches using individual
search engines.
Monitoring
The previous tactic, searching, involves an active initiative
to locate relevant information. The opposite approach, one that
saves considerable time, is a passive information seeking strategy.
That is, someone else collects the information you desire and
periodically report the results to you. Three tactics are described
which utilize technology to monitor topics of personal and professional
interest.
Tactic #4 Subscribe to a Monitoring Service
A strategy similar to subscribing to a listserv, (Tactic
#2) involves subscribing to a service that conducts its own monitoring
and provides periodic updates. Two examples of services that
monitor education and technology topics are:
The Scout Report
http://scout.cs.wisc.edu/index.html
EDUPAGE
http://www.educause.com/pub/edupage/edupage.html
Obviously, the value of this tactic is dependent on the quality
of the search staff that prepares the messages. In my experience,
I've found that the quality of the resources shared via monitoring
services to be significantly higher than those exchanged via
e-conferences.
Tactic #5 Create a Personalized News Monitor
Personalized news monitors are essentially customizable web
pages that
allow users to define the news and current events that they want
to
monitor. Begin by selecting the items you want (e.g., headlines,
sports, TV
guide listings, weather, etc.), and then customize the layout.
Subsequently, whenever you visit the page, you see only the news
that
interests you. Examples of personalized news monitors can be
found at the
following web sites:
My Yahoo!
http://my.yahoo.com
Create Your Own Newspaper
http://crayon.net
My Excite Start Page
http://my.excite.com
While this approach places a premium on monitoring the popular
press, it
can be a useful tool. Be sure to look for the Clipping Service
function that will allow you to create and store a search profile
about topics of interest. Whenever you review the profile you
will find articles from papers around the country/world on your
topic. This tactic is clearly an example of the power of technology
tools that would be difficult to
replicate using traditional resources.
Tactic #6 Create a Selective Dissemination of Information
(SDI) Profile
To take advantage of this tactic you will probably need to
enlist the assistance of a university librarian. Selective Dissemination
of Information (SDI) is a procedure that involves creating a
search request to be executed in a specific database. Once your
search profile is created, your search will be run every time
the database is updated (i.e., monthly, quarterly) and you will
be automatically notified of the new items indexed by the descriptors
in your search profile. To learn more about SDI, visit:
Bibliography of Selective Dissemination of Information
http://www.ils.unc.edu/gants/sdibib.html
SilverPlatter
http://www.silverplatter.com/support/docs/webspirs41/ws41qs13.htm
While this feature is not currently available for ERIC, some
local libraries, database providers, and third-party vendors
provide this service. Unlike most methods of literature searching
that require you to initiate the search, this tactic is a passive
method for staying current since you periodically and automatically
receive notification of new items meeting the definition of your
search profile. Without question, this
tactic is extremely valuable for scholars.
Pathfinding
Historically, scholars have published literature reviews
and annotated bibliographies as a means of helping others access
the body of knowledge that inform an expert's understanding of
a discipline. However, when conducting leading-edge work, it
is unlikely that a comprehensive review is yet available. Further,
complicating matters, without a colleague to share new resources,
many scholars, technology specialists, and educational leaders
find themselves working in relative isolation. I use the term,
"pathfinding," to connote an application of technology
that allows a person to benefit from the noteworthy resources
concerning a topic that other researchers and practitioners would
recommend to others interested in learning more about a topic.
Below are three pathfinding tactics I've discovered for utilizing
technology to access articles, books, and web sites that others
have found valuable in their study of a specific topic.
Tactic #7 Access Recommended Articles
Searches of databases like ERIC yield lists of recently published
articles. However, how can you find out which articles appear
to be receiving more attention than others? One interesting way
to go about this is to access the database of a document delivery
system. A document delivery service allows users to locate relevant
articles and order a copy of the article to be delivered via
mail, fax, or email. One popular document delivery service is:
UnCoverWeb 2.0
http://uncweb.carl.org/
Why would you search a database like UnCover rather than ERIC?
A search of
the database of a document delivery service will not produce
all the articles on your topic; only the articles that have been
frequently requested. Thus, conduct your traditional search using
ERIC to obtain a comprehensive list of articles and then search
CARL UnCover to locate articles that should move up on your priority
list. Unless you order a copy of an article, this service is
free. If you have a colleague who is an expert on your topic
and can help you rank order your search results for relevance
and priority you'll have little need for this tactic. Otherwise,
this technique is excellent
Tactic #8 Access Recommended Books
Most readers are familiar with Amazon.com at some level.
However, have you
thought about how this online service can assist you in your
research? Go ahead and connect and search for a book title you
commonly reference in your work.
Amazon.com
http://amazon.com
Scroll down the page past the descriptions and notice the list
of recommended books. The list of recommended books is built
from a database regarding the purchases by people that also bought
the book you referenced. While we all have different interests,
affinity groups can be composed of people share common interests.
As a result, techniques derived from affinity groups can be applied
to suggest books that might interest you. As a researcher, this
type of list is invaluable for making me aware of related books
that I perhaps have yet to discover in my work. Best of all,
its free!
Tactic #9 Access Recommended Website
While one might expect tools for locating articles and books
to be more advanced given their traditional use in scholarship,
wouldn't it be helpful if there were similar tools for locating
recommended web pages? If so, you may be interested in knowing
about a free browser plug-in that provides users with a pathfinding
function for any web page you visit. Go to the following web
page, take the tour to learn about Alexa and then download the
free software (select the version for the web browser you are
using):
Alexa
http://www.alexa.com
After Alexa is installed, a small window appears across the bottom
of your screen anytime your web browser is open. For any web
page you visit, Alexa provides information about who owns the
web site, its ranking in terms of hits, and a list of up to ten
web sites that visitors to that page frequently visit. The value
of this tool is immeasurable. While each of the ten related sites
are not always helpful, on many occasions they have created links
for me that would have taken hours to discover otherwise. I believe
this is a "must-have" tool for everyone: students,
technology specialists, educational leaders, and researchers.
Concluding Thoughts
Bush (1945) noted that our ability to extend the record has
greatly surpassed our ability to consult and exploit the knowledge
base in its bulk: "The summation of human experience is
being expended at a prodigious rate, and the means we use for
threading through the consequent maze to the momentarily important
item is the same as was used in the days of square-rigged ships."
(p. 102).
In summary, while Bush's quote still holds true, new developments
are emerging which suggest interesting possibilities for research
and practice. As outlined in Table 1, nine tactics illustrate
the value of technology tools and tactics for navigating overwhelming
amounts of information to find that which is personally and professionally
relevant and useful.
It appears that Tactic #1 (attending a conference) is a baseline
strategy that has proven its value historically. Tactic #2 (joining
an e-conference) certainly fills the void when travel budgets
are reduced and may sustain on-going collaboration between conference
meetings. However the time required to sort through voluminous
messages raises questions about the value of this tactic given
the time and effort involved. Typical web searching (Tactic #3)
seems to epitomize Bush's (1945) observation about the antiquated
tools presently available. In contrast, Tactics #4, 5, &
6 (monitors) seem to offer an economical trade-off in terms of
value of results in exchange for minimal time and effort. Finally,
Tactics #7, 8, & 9 (pathfinding) begin to illustrate how
the unique power of technology (i.e., affinity groups, e-commerce,
one-to-one databases) can be harnessed to enhance scholarship
by providing current awareness information in ways that are without
a counterpart.
References
Bush, V. (1945, July). As we may think. Atlantic Monthly,
pp. 101-108.
Table 1
Cluster of Nine Tactics for Using Technology to Maintain Current
Awareness
____________________________________________________
Networking
Tactic 1 Attend a Conference
Tactic 2 Join an E-Conference
Searching
Tactic 3 Conduct a Web Search
Monitoring
Tactic 4 Subscribe to a Monitoring Service
Tactic 5 Create a Personalized News Monitor
Tactic 6 Create an SDI Profile
Pathfinding
Tactic 7 Access Recommended Articles
Tactic 8 Access Recommended Books
Tactic 9 Access Recommended Website
|